
I've honestly never liked Pendulum's attempts at making drum'n'bass. To me, almost all of these early tracks sounded like somebody just said "ok, I think drum'n'bass is pretty cool, we should do something like that" - and that's actually pretty much how it was. While I would never dare question Rob Swire's creativity and originality, most of their early material just felt somehow forced, unnatural, un-drum'n'bass-y. Hold Your Colour is, I think, pretty good, but as I said: it feels forced. In Silico, released in 2008, is a source of much more hate from the DnB community, me included. In it, Pendulum have returned to their pre-Pendulum rock roots and it really showed. While the album did attract a fair number of new fans, for some of which it has been the "gateway drug" to "real" drum'n'bass, it mostly just shed bad light on the scene from which Pendulum's earlier sound grew.
Immersion, on the other hand, sees Pendulum as a much more mature musical project. It is evident that Rob Swire has finally begun to find his own style instead of just copying and trying to mimic something which wasn't made for him. You can hear both the DnB influence and the rock background in the sound of this album and, unlike In Silico, they have been made, surely through endless hours of toiling, to work extremely well together. As any album, though, it isn't uniform. It has its strong points and it has weak ones.
The opening track called Salt In The Wounds, which is preceded only by the - awkward at best - short fanfare Genesis, is one of these weak points. It tries to be Slam, but fails and it's more repetitive than any of their other songs have ever been. There isn't even the super-strong, massive melodic line that I've grown to expect from this kind of Pendulum track. It's not terrible, but it's most certainly not amazing.
Following that is Watercolour, which I'm pretty sure you've already heard by now. I actually don't really know what to say about this. While I definitely don't hate it, I think that the hype that was built around this track could've been better off directed elsewhere. The vocals are smooth and well-performed, which is a good thing. Everything fits together, so I can't really find anything to nitpick here. As a work of musical craftsmanship, Watercolour is of extraordinarily high quality, but it doesn't have much else aside from that.
Set Me On Fire is an experiment in an area where Pendulum have almost not set foot before - dubstep. It's extremely well-produced and generally very good. While both of the previous tracks were quite obvious attempts to remind the listener of Pendulum's previous works - Salt In The Wounds being, as mentioned, a bastardized clone of Slam and Watercolour being Propane Nightmares remade and refined - Set Me On Fire is certainly something completely, or at least mostly, new. And I like that. I really do. The bass is thick enough to slice and knead and everything else works together.
While I certainly enjoyed the beginning of the album, Crush is where it really begins to take off. The synths have been sent on vacation, appearing only as subtle support to the main instrument, which, here, is the guitar. The vocals are good, perhaps the best of the entire album and I generally don't have anything bad to say about it. Way to go, Pendulum. Or at least I would say that if it wasn't for...
Under The Waves. Let's face it, people, Under The Waves sucks donkey balls. High-pitched synths are playing a melody that sounds like Pendulum stole it from Ferry Corsten and I swear, Rob Swire's voice has never sounded this gay. The amen break that provides the backdrop has almost no variance throughout the whole song. Seriously. This track sounds like something made in Reason by a 13-year old who has just discovered John B. and desperately wants to be like him, only to fail terribly and - so to speak - epicly. I couldn't have imagined a worse letdown after something as good and as action-packed as Crush. For a moment, I seriously considered stopping the playback after this track ended.
In retrospect, I'm glad I didn't. The fact that the next song, Immunize, has Liam Howlett's name next to it, probably helped. I thought: "well, this better be good". If it wasn't good, I was, in all seriousness, going to turn it all off and just give up on Pendulum altogether. Thankfully, it is good. Oh yes. It is very good. If you've heard the Pendulum remix of Voodoo People, you might have some idea what Pendulum and The Prodigy sound like combined, but a remix is still worlds below a collaboration. And this is a collaboration. This is, actually, one of the best collaborations I've ever heard. This song takes the best out of both worlds and turns it into one massive, screaming and kicking mass of awesomeness. Pendulum always did borrow a little from the Prodigy - after all, who doesn't - but in here, it's taken to the next level. My will to live - and listen - on has been rekindled.
Next up is a two-part track called The Island. The first part is subtitled "Dawn" and is actually pretty generic. The melody is joyful and fills you (or it at least did that for me) with images of some kind of tropical paradise, palms included. It could've gone without the vocals this time, but that's really a hard thing to balance out. They aren't too bad, though. The second part, Dusk, is almost a minute shorter than the first and it's a shame, because it's way better. The funky, pumping rhythm is something I'd love to jump up and down to, even though I really didn't expect Pendulum, of all the bands out there, to put out something like this, even after Set Me On Fire. Where the first part soothed and smoothened, the second part breaks and corrupts, in the best way imaginable.
It almost prepares you for what awaits next. Comprachicos. A hissing, maleficient whisper sounds like it's been cropped out of some sort of nu-metal song, but it hasn't, because right after it follows something far more normal - Rob Swire's dashing approach to singing brings us a few lines, before it all breaks down into the most insane, broken beast of a drum'n'bass chorus ever. If I needed to compare this to something from the DnB scene, I'd say... Noisia. Pumping, fat... damn. It's good and it's Pendulum. It's over before it even properly begins, though. Really, it's the shortest song on the entire album, a honor I'd much rather hand to Salt In The Wounds, which is really the same bar set on repeat for six minutes straight anyway.
The Vulture is up next. While with Comprachicos, the influence of other artists has been pretty subtle, here I just can't not say it - this is Hadouken!, plain and simple. It's still very good, I just think it could use a little more originality.
Oh, Witchcraft. For a long time, I didn't know what to say about it. It opens almost like a rock ballad - hell, exactly like a rock ballad. After that, it changes to straight-up hard rock with hardly an ounce of drum'n'bass, or, well, anything else thrown in. I think Pendulum could make a pretty decent living making just songs like this, but thankfully they don't seem to be content with being stagnant.
Just as I was anxious to hear what Liam Howlett could bring to Pendulum, I was afraid of what In Flames could take away from them. And as far as I can tell, my worries were justified. Self vs. Self is, in my opinion, pretty bad. The vocals are partially done by the In Flames singer (well, that or Rob Swire can actually make his balls drop and then recall them back on command) and that sucks. The guitars are too distorted. I imagine Pendulum and In Flames must've had a lot of fun working on this, but since metal just isn't my cup of tea, I can't bring myself to enjoy this. But I guess it's actually genuinely good, just not what I like, so it's still far better than Under The Waves, which just sucks as a whole.
Aaaand... another "feat." thinger. The Fountain is its name and it would've been a fitting end to an album as awesome as this one. The melody is really fantastic and as I was listening, I saw a thousand AMV makers wake up and grab their tools, because this is just AMV material par excellence. Other than that, it's just a really, really good song that works both in itself and in the context of the album. Good job, Pendulum. If I were to stop the album after The Fountain, I could go to sleep a happy man.
But there's this little disgrace at the end. It's called Encoder. I was initially reminded of the Chemical Brothers' Galvanize by the initial chords. But that ended soon. The rest of the song is cheap, sweet, dull and radiates a false aura of stupid niceness. Well, actually not the WHOLE rest of the song. Much like The Tempest, it ends with a part that's really a cut above the first part. So yeah, had the whole song been like its latter half, it would've been better.
And then, it all ends with sounds of someone swimming. Or something. I honestly don't know what it's supposed to symbolize.
All in all, I can safely say that this is the best Pendulum album yet. Pendulum have finally managed to break free from all of the chains that were holding them in place and have begun moving towards a better, brighter future for all of us - a future where Pendulum is no longer to drum'n'bass what Naruto is to anime - the bait that brings an awful lot of retards into the fanbase. I genuinely enjoy this album, because it no longer tries as hard as before to be DnB and that really helps it become actually good.
